Time Synchronisation

This article explores how to use national time and frequency radio transmissions for network time synchronisation.

The importance of an authenticated timing reference to synchronise a computer network to, cannot be stressed highly enough.

While there are hundreds and quite possibly thousands of internet based timing sources these can’t be authenticated leaving a system open to viruses, malicious hackers or malware.

Furthermore, a survey by MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) found that nearly half of internet timing sources were offset by over ten seconds and only a third could be regarded as being ‘useful ’ also it was discovered that many were too far away from peers to provide any useful accuracy.

Most dedicated network time servers are designed to receive a timing signal from the GPS (Global Positioning System), primarily because it is the most accurate and can be received from anywhere on the globe.

However, there are situations where it may not be practical to use a GPS time server. A GPS antenna has to be situated on a rooftop and have a clear view of the sky which may prove difficult if the server is on the ground floor of a multi-storey sky-scraper. Many administrators also dislike the hassle and expense of having to run a cable up a building and install an antenna or if there are possibilities the server room maybe relocated and the process has to be repeated.

Fortunately many countries’ national physics laboratories broadcast a time and frequency signal from a radio transmitter. In the US the signal is referred to as WWVB and is broadcast by NIST (National Institute for Standards and Technology) in Colorado. In the UK the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) broadcasts the MSF signal from Cumbria and similar systems are broadcast in Germany (DCF-77), Japan (JJY) and France (TDF).

Unfortunately not every country transmits a national time and frequency broadcast so if a time server is to be located outside of the US, Germany, UK, France or Japan it may be doubtful that a signal could be received (although many of the these transmissions can be received in neighbouring countries).

Radio signals are also easily susceptible to atmospheric interference and can be blocked by mountains, sky-scrapers or other topography. However, an upside to using a radio receiver is that it will receive a signal inside a building.

While a radio transmission is not as accurate as a GPS time signal a dedicated network time server receiving a radio signal can still provide accuracy between 1 – 20 milliseconds (a millisecond is 1/1000 of a second) which is more than adequate for the needs of network synchronisation.

Time is essential for modern computer networks, as the majority of applications and processes conducted by a PC are  reliant on a timestamp, from sending an email, debugging a server to preventing fraud, therefore, accurate time and synchronisation is vital.

NTP (Network Time Protocol) is an Internet protocol designed for the synchronisation of computer networks. NTP servers are used by millions of system administrators to ensure their networks are keeping accurate time.

However, just as a computer is only as a good as the software it is running, a NTP server is only as good as the timing source it receives.

Despite the hundreds and probably thousands of possible timing references on the Internet, administrators should be aware of some of the possible pitfalls in selecting a timing reference.

A survey conducted by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) discovered that not only were half of Internet timing sources inaccurate by over a ten seconds (a lifetime if we are attempting millisecond accuracy) but many were too far away to be provide any useful accuracy.

If an Internet timing source is to be used then not only should the accuracy of the server be checked but also the closest host should be selected to ensure the best accuracy.

Another consideration in using an Internet timing source is to be aware that they cannot be authenticated which means that your system could be vulnerable to malicious attacks and it is recommended by Microsoft and Novell that an external hardware source should be used.

The most secure and accurate method of receiving a timing source is to use a dedicated NTP server that can receive either a national time and frequency transmission (such as WWVB in the US or MSF in the UK). Alternatively a timing source can be received from the GPS network (Global Positioning System), both methods are authenticated and can provide millisecond accuracy.

Time is essential for modern computer networks, as the majority of applications and processes conducted by a PC are  reliant on a timestamp, from sending an email, debugging a server to preventing fraud, therefore, accurate time and synchronisation is vital.

NTP (Network Time Protocol) is an Internet protocol designed for the synchronisation of computer networks. NTP servers are used by millions of system administrators to ensure their networks are keeping accurate time.

However, just as a computer is only as a good as the software it is running, a NTP server is only as good as the timing source it receives.

Despite the hundreds and probably thousands of possible timing references on the Internet, administrators should be aware of some of the possible pitfalls in selecting a timing reference.

A survey conducted by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) discovered that not only were half of Internet timing sources inaccurate by over a ten seconds (a lifetime if we are attempting millisecond accuracy) but many were too far away to be provide any useful accuracy.

If an Internet timing source is to be used then not only should the accuracy of the server be checked but also the closest host should be selected to ensure the best accuracy.

Another consideration in using an Internet timing source is to be aware that they cannot be authenticated which means that your system could be vulnerable to malicious attacks and it is recommended by Microsoft and Novell that an external hardware source should be used.

The most secure and accurate method of receiving a timing source is to use a dedicated NTP server that can receive either a national time and frequency transmission (such as WWVB in the US or MSF in the UK). Alternatively a timing source can be received from the GPS network (Global Positioning System), both methods are authenticated and can provide millisecond accuracy.

This article explores how to use national time and frequency radio transmissions for network time synchronisation.

The importance of an authenticated timing reference to synchronise a computer network to, cannot be stressed highly enough.

While there are hundreds and quite possibly thousands of internet based timing sources these can’t be authenticated leaving a system open to viruses, malicious hackers or malware.

Furthermore, a survey by MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology) found that nearly half of internet timing sources were offset by over ten seconds and only a third could be regarded as being ‘useful ’ also it was discovered that many were too far away from peers to provide any useful accuracy.

Most dedicated network time servers are designed to receive a timing signal from the GPS (Global Positioning System), primarily because it is the most accurate and can be received from anywhere on the globe.

However, there are situations where it may not be practical to use a GPS time server. A GPS antenna has to be situated on a rooftop and have a clear view of the sky which may prove difficult if the server is on the ground floor of a multi-storey sky-scraper. Many administrators also dislike the hassle and expense of having to run a cable up a building and install an antenna or if there are possibilities the server room maybe relocated and the process has to be repeated.

Fortunately many countries’ national physics laboratories broadcast a time and frequency signal from a radio transmitter. In the US the signal is referred to as WWVB and is broadcast by NIST (National Institute for Standards and Technology) in Colorado. In the UK the National Physical Laboratory (NPL) broadcasts the MSF signal from Cumbria and similar systems are broadcast in Germany (DCF-77), Japan (JJY) and France (TDF).

Unfortunately not every country transmits a national time and frequency broadcast so if a time server is to be located outside of the US, Germany, UK, France or Japan it may be doubtful that a signal could be received (although many of the these transmissions can be received in neighbouring countries).

Radio signals are also easily susceptible to atmospheric interference and can be blocked by mountains, sky-scrapers or other topography. However, an upside to using a radio receiver is that it will receive a signal inside a building.

While a radio transmission is not as accurate as a GPS time signal a dedicated network time server receiving a radio signal can still provide accuracy between 1 – 20 milliseconds (a millisecond is 1/1000 of a second) which is more than adequate for the needs of network synchronisation.

Atomic clocks are incredibly expensive and generally they are normally only to be found in large scale physics laboratories such as MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology), NIST (National Institute of Standards and Technology (Colorado) or the National Physical Laboratory in the UK.

Fortunately many national laboratories broadcast the UTC (Coordinated Universal Time) time from their atomic clocks via a radio transmission.

In the US the national timing broadcast is called WWVB and is broadcast by NIST (National Institute fro Standards and Time) in Fort Collins, Colorado. The WWVB broadcast is used by millions of people throughout North America to synchronize consumer electronic products like wall clocks, clock radios, and wristwatches. In addition, WWVB is used for high-level applications such as network time synchronization utilizing NTP.

The time code contains the year, day of year, hour, minute, second, and flags that indicate the status of Daylight Saving Time, leap years, and leap seconds.

WWVB broadcasts on 2.5, 5, 10, 15, and 20 MHz and for most users in the United States, the received accuracy should be less than 10 milliseconds (1/100 of a second).

While many NTP servers now use GPS to receive a timing reference, the advantage of using a radio transmission is that a signal can be received indoors (a GPS antenna needs a good view of the sky).

However, the radio signal has a finite range and can be blocked by skyscrapers, mountains and dense conurbations. A radio based NTP server usually consists of a rack-mountable time server, and an antenna, consisting of a ferrite bar inside a plastic enclosure, which receives the radio time and frequency broadcast. The antenna should always be mounted horizontally at a right angle toward the transmission for optimum signal strength.

Similar national timing transmissions are broadcast from other countries in the UK the signal is referred to as MSF and is broadcast by the National Physical Laboratory in Cumbria, other systems are broadcast in Frankfurt, Germany (DCF-77), Japan (JJY) and France (TDF)

Atomic clocks are incredibly expensive and generally they are normally only to be found in large scale physics laboratories such as MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology), NIST (National Institute of Standards and Technology (Colorado) or the National Physical Laboratory in the UK.

Fortunately many national laboratories broadcast the UTC (Coordinated Universal Time) time from their atomic clocks via a radio broadcast.

In the UK the national timing broadcast is called MSF and is broadcast by NPL (National Physical Laboratory) in Cumbria. The MSF broadcast is used by throughout the UK and parts of Europe to synchronise consumer electronic products like wall clocks, clock radios, and wristwatches. In addition, MSF is used for high-level applications such as network time synchronisation utilising NTP.

The time code contains the year, day of year, hour, minute, second, and flags that indicate the status of Daylight Saving Time, leap years, and leap seconds.

MSF operates on a frequency of 60 kHz and carries a time and date code that can be received and decoded by a wide range of readily available radio-controlled clocks and provides a received accuracy should be less than 10 milliseconds (1/100 of a second).

While many NTP servers now use GPS to receive a timing reference, the advantage of using a radio transmission is that a signal can be received indoors (a GPS antenna needs a good view of the sky).

However, the radio signal has a finite range and can be blocked by skyscrapers, mountains and dense conurbations. A radio based NTP server usually consists of a rack-mountable time server, and an antenna, consisting of a ferrite bar inside a plastic enclosure, which receives the radio time and frequency broadcast. The antenna should always be mounted horizontally at a right angle toward the transmission for optimum signal strength.

Similar national timing transmissions are broadcast from other countries in the US the signal is referred to as WWVB and is broadcast by the NIST (National Institute for Standards and Technology) in Fort Collins, Colorado, other systems are broadcast in Frankfurt, Germany (DCF-77), Japan (JJY) and France (TDF).

What time is it? One of the commonest questions uttered around the World but what exactly are we asking? You ask someone in China what the time is then you will certainly get a different answer if you ask an American, obviously their time-zones are on the opposite side of the world.

But what if you ask two people in the same room as you? You may get the same answer from them both but then again one person’s watch may be a minute or two faster.

When we ask the time then what we are really asking for is a rough estimate for the time zone that we are in. Some watches are more accurate than others but it is often enough for our day to day needs.

But what if you need to know the exact time and what if you need to know what that time is another country too. Perhaps you have bought an airline ticket; it would be disappointing to turn up at the airport only to be told that your ticket was sold to somebody else in as the clock at their travel agent was slower than the one where you bought your ticket.

So how does global industry keep accurate time with one another? The answer is quite simple and it is called Coordinated Universal Time or UTC.

The International Bureau of Weights and Measures (BIPM) acts as the official time-keeper for the globe and started UTC in 1972 after the development of atomic clocks.

The atomic clock was first developed in the late 50’s when it was discovered the atom caesium-133 resonates at an exact frequency of 9,192,631,770 every second. This frequency was so exact that atomic clocks developed an accuracy of one second in 1.4million years and The International System of Units defined the second as the frequency of the caesium-133 atom and an international unit for measuring time was born.

However, atomic clocks are even more accurate than the Earth itself which is actually slowing in its rotation. This slowing is only small but if the standard system of time, UTC, didn’t compensate for it, eventually midnight would fall in the middle of the day (although that would take a millennia or two) so leap seconds are added every few years to compensate.

The only problem with UTC timepieces is that atomic clocks are enormous in both size and cost. In fact they are generally only to be found in large scale physics laboratories such as NPL (National Physics Laboratory, UK) or MIT (Massachusetts Institute of Technology, US).

Then how does the rest of the world keep track of UTC time? The time told on these vast atomic clocks is broadcast via radio broadcasts or the GPS satellite system (Satellite Navigation is reliant on UTC as without it a satellite can’t tell exactly where a receiver is).

Most computer networks are sycnhronised to UTC time either over the Internet (which isn’t secure and only recommended for home users) or through specialist GPS or radio time servers. These time servers make use of NTP (Network Time Protocol) which has been developed over the last 25 years to keep computer networks synchronized so they do not have to rely on their inaccurate internal clocks.

NTP servers and UTC have allowed industry to become truly global and made possible technologies such as communication satellites, mobile phones, sat-nav and ATM’s that we all take for granted.